Played with alot of this yesterday, here's a quick rundown:
Club is practically an exact dupe for Burmese Beauty shadow (Dark green one). I swatched them side by side and the only noticiable difference is texture, BB has a deeper brown base and the shimmer in Club leans more teal while BB is a smidge more green. If you have Club, Skintone 2 and Showstopper shadows you do not need this quad. Club is listed in our book as working name & a dupe for BB. I guess my Club has lost a bit of it's luster lol! Don't get me wrong the quad is really pretty it's just not necessary if you have similar colors already. Kittenish is just as pretty as everyone thinks, hopes and wants it to be.
The liners are opaque, shimmery and long-lasting. After 4-6 handwashings the swathes were still there AND shimmering. They are easy to apply and can easily produce thin or thick lines. They have long, slim, conical, spongy tips.
Palace Pedigreed quad is easily the most pigmented. It's really pretty and reminds me of rich Victorian colors you'd see alot of in vintage clothing and furniture. Really pretty. The nudes and berry shades were my fave. More suited for cooler skintones but anyone could easily wear it.
Leopard Luxe Quad is really pretty. Our trainer did the prettiest sheer smoky eye with it! The Furiously Fabulous Shadow (Black) will easily make this uber popular. It's not just black it has this burnished golden orange shimmer lurking about in its frost. Really Pretty. The orange is adorable too, think orange dreamsicle in frosty shadow form.