I would tend to agree but the exception that Pet Me is my favorite blush ever. Yes, the pay off isn't as nice as products from Naturally or Tres Cheek, but it has a special place in my heart. If they ever make it again with the new, improved formula, I would be ecstatic.
I have ordered at least 15 times and never had a problem, everything appears to be quite authentic. Then again, I have never had to return anything, and I have read that can be a pain, but I have been 100% satisfied with them, except soemtimes the pricing is a little more than I would pay (then I just get it somewhere else). But as to the products being authentic and not being defective, unless it is stated in the description that there are scratches or missing box, etc., it has been fine and as described. I never got anything that smelled off, was wrong consistency, dried up, etc...