I think people rely too much on T's reviews/swatches. She is only one person, and only one person's thoughts. If you are like me and cannot get to a MAC store, take Specktra as a REALLY great place to talk to MANY people who get to see the items and give really good reviews. Please don't think Temptalia's site is your only option. She of course has never been a fan of MES so she isn't going to really play with them and work with them. Had it been months ago I would have waited to see her swatches and then ordered, had I done that with this collection I probably wouldn't have gotten anything. There are some really really great people on here who provide IN DEPTH details on products and really are there to give helpful comments.
So - with all that being said, don't shy away from products just because T doesn't like them. Read back pages on here, you will find some good info and other swatches!