MAC Nasty Gal Collection (Dec 4, 2014)
- Thread starter erine1881
- Start date
LavenderPearl
Well-known member
Gunner is pretty but still :fluffy: Just realized I haven't even touched Instigator or Punk Couture since December 28, 2013 
;;;
;;;
Vandekamp
Well-known member
I was not a fan of Instigator or PC. Gunner does look pretty. Unfortunately, it is not pretty enough to buy. LolGunner is pretty but still :fluffy: Just realized I haven't even touched Instigator or Punk Couture since December 28, 2013
Mizani
Well-known member
You ain't ever lied. Foreal.
I was *just* playing around on T's dupe page and compared Kinky to Stunner. The two are almost identical. Problem is...because of that, now I want it!! Instead of debating whether to get a back up of Kinky (knowing I probably wouldn't finish my one and only) now I can feel justified with Stunner cause it is not the same lipstick. My oh my I got a problem. But I don't care!
I also played around comparing Runner to a couple of other deep colors in the same range off the top of my head. It looks VERY close to Sin. Only difference is, Sin reads more cool and wine compared to Runner which looks more burgundy in comparison. Also compared it to TTT that is more plum and Fixed On Drama that looks similar to it but only a little lighter and a tinge more red.
Vandekamp
Well-known member
If you are looking for another excuse to buy another red, this is it.
oke: The struggle is REAL!!! This year I bought all of the KVD red lipsticks, Bite's Tannin, VGR1, Kinky (2), UD's Mrs. Mia Wallace and a few that I can't think of right now.
Mizani
Well-known member
The struggle IS real!
Got so many reds that are in the same family and here I am planning more. Oh well.
After this I will finally be officially thru with MAC for a while and can set my sight on one of those Tom Ford minis!
NaomiH
Well-known member
We sure have been!
Vandekamp
Well-known member
Sure you will. Lol.The struggle IS real! Got so many reds that are in the same family and here I am planning more. Oh well.
Mizani
Well-known member
Oh I will. LOL! None of the colors in MAC's upcoming collections over the next three months really appeal to me. The problem with these colors in all these fall collections is that a LOT of them appealed to me cause they are the colors I'm drawn to. Even though I already own something similar.
MRV
Well-known member
This is all good news to me! I don't have Sin (and I prefer warms), TTT (don't like plums) nor FOD!You ain't ever lied. Foreal.
I was *just* playing around on T's dupe page and compared Kinky to Stunner. The two are almost identical. Problem is...because of that, now I want it!! Instead of debating whether to get a back up of Kinky (knowing I probably wouldn't finish my one and only) now I can feel justified with Stunner cause it is not the same lipstick. My oh my I got a problem. But I don't care!
I also played around comparing Runner to a couple of other deep colors in the same range off the top of my head. It looks VERY close to Sin. Only difference is, Sin reads more cool and wine compared to Runner which looks more burgundy in comparison. Also compared it to TTT that is more plum and Fixed On Drama that looks similar to it but only a little lighter and a tinge more red.
Mizani
Well-known member
Christine has her full review up now. She compared Runner to the same colors I did.
But once again, the one I was most interested in is the most troublesome.
But she did state that Stunner was easy to apply. Hopefully it is more similar to Kinky in that regard.
It is funny, all this time I would have guessed that Kinky would be the pinkier of the two but apparently it is Stunner. I had already noticed that when I did the comparison swatch and she mentioned it as well.
But once again, the one I was most interested in is the most troublesome.
It is funny, all this time I would have guessed that Kinky would be the pinkier of the two but apparently it is Stunner. I had already noticed that when I did the comparison swatch and she mentioned it as well.
CrimsonQuill157
Well-known member
It doesn't look like T had the same problems with the lipsticks that Karen did. Definitely getting Gunner.
Mizani
Well-known member
Yeah, especially regarding Stunner. Though her saying that Runner felt grainy is concerning.
SassyWonder
Well-known member
I have no patience for bad formula lippies! Mac had more then enough time to get these right especially after all the date changes. This is a def skip!
jenise
Well-known member
Me too!
NaomiH
Well-known member
:werd: If it feels dry, doesn't go on fully opaque in one swipe and doesn't apply evenly, it can go kick some rocks! I'm too spoiled now to settle for anything less. Lol
