MAC Nasty Gal Collection (Dec 4, 2014)

[SassyWonder]

:werd: If it feels dry, doesn't go on fully opaque in one swipe and doesn't apply evenly, it can go kick some rocks! I'm too spoiled now to settle for anything less. Lol

Not a dime will go to so so makeup when there's amazing out there. Theres no NEED feeling anymore. The hype doesn't work. I want quality or nada!

 

[lipstickpd23]

http://www.temptalia.com/mac-nasty-gal-lipsticks-gunner-runner-stunner-reviews-photos-swatches Her review says that Runner and Gunner are more Satin than Matte. I wonder how true that is. I can't wait to swatch!

 

[NaomiH]

Not a dime will go to so so makeup when there's amazing out there. Theres no NEED feeling anymore. The hype doesn't work. I want quality or nada!

Not one dime! I see Runner and it's beautiful, but I have Sin, Diva and Fixed on Drama and if I want another colour in that range I'll get Black Dahlia.

 

[MandyVanHook]

Hmm, I don't hate T's swatch of Gunner... now I might consider that one. :/

 

[OctoberViolet]

Gunner!!!!!!

Happy Thanksgiving, everyone!!!!!!

 

[MandyVanHook]

I think this is the first time I've seen T make something look better than Karen.

 

[Marsha Pomells]

http://www.temptalia.com/mac-nasty-gal-lipsticks-gunner-runner-stunner-reviews-photos-swatches Her review says that Runner and Gunner are more Satin than Matte. I wonder how true that is. I can't wait to swatch!

I hate to say this... I think I'm giving in to Gunner... But then again, I do own 2 PCs and Kontrol (which needs replacing), I'll think about it

I think this is the first time I've seen T make something look better than Karen.

After seeing the pics for both reviews, I second that

 

[Dolly Snow]

Her review says that Runner and Gunner are more Satin than Matte. I wonder how true that is. I can't wait to swatch!

They look good on her, and I don't see patchy, nasty, cracked lips...but then she does put on a million layers

 

[Marsha Pomells]

They look good on her, and I don't see patchy, nasty, cracked lips...but then she does put on a million layers...sooooo 

What are the chances that Christine prepped her lips before swatching, if there is an issue with the formula? Cos I don't see an formula issue

 

[Dolly Snow]

Cos I don't see an formula issue

She does a lot of lip swatches so she may have prepped them before. But then again so does Karen.

 

[CrimsonQuill157]

They look good on her, and I don't see patchy, nasty, cracked lips...but then she does put on a million layers...sooooo 

I put on several layers usually, so if that's the case, then its an accurate depiction for what I'm looking for.

 

[NaomiH]

I don't see Karen being someone who wouldn't do lip prep before swatching. Still a super mega skip for me as not a single thing is appealing to me, but I hope everyone who buys gets T's result and not Karen's.

 

[Marsha Pomells]

I put on several layers usually, so if that's the case, then its an accurate depiction for what I'm looking for.

Same here, but it depends on the finish. Plus my lips are quite pigmented, so it might take less layers than TTT (I have to layer that on, just to hide the patchiness)

 

[Dolly Snow]

I don't see Karen being someone who wouldn't do lip prep before swatching. Still a super mega skip for me as not a single thing is appealing to me, but I hope everyone who buys gets T's result and not Karen's.

I hope for the same Naomi and I am with you

 

[Vandekamp]

I think this is the first time I've seen T make something look better than Karen.

 

[BreeMakeupGeek]

I think I want Gunner & Stunner.....leaning more towards Stunner. I don't think vampy/dark lipsticks suit me. Lol I've been wearing Reds & Hot Pinks for to loooong

 

[BreeMakeupGeek]

:werd: Amen!!!! The more I hear of reviews like this I becomee more and more annoyed with Mac. Mac is part of THE largest makeup company in the world. It's just unacceptable!!

  

Really??? T's reviews & photos apply more to me than K's + she rarely if ever gives an item a F even when its deserving, IDK, maybe everything works perfectly for her

 

[nikkideevah]

Sigh I don't know now.. When I saw Karen's swatches I was like hell no.. Now I'm torn.. I really don't need anything but I got a $50 gift card recently.. Guess I will hold on lol

 

[Mizani]

I do too, but T seems to over apply is all I meant eace: I hope for the same Naomi and I am with you :fluffy:

Really??? T's reviews & photos apply more to me than K's + she rarely if ever gives an item a F even when its deserving, IDK, maybe everything works perfectly for her

 

[Dolly Snow]

See, I think the opposite about T. I think she applies lipstick realistically and how I do, full opacity. It is Karen who doesn't apply enough color for me. Lol

Lol are you picking up any?