MAC Nasty Gal Collection (Dec 4, 2014)

dcarrington

Well-known member
It just irks me that I have PC right now. I know if I get Gunner that PC will collect duct. Its not the best going on. And also I read someone ask about SR. I didn't see a comparison swatch for them. Would you get one if you had the other?
 

MissElle12

Well-known member
I don't have photos, and I don't own SR (yet hahaha), but I can try some snaps tomorrow maybe with FNF and Stunner. Those two aren't very close, though. Oblivion would be an interesting comparison with Stunner, although it's a different finish.

With photos, either I bust them out quickly and not give a hoot that the color isn't accurate or I fiddle and fiddle with them to make sure the color is close, and it still isn't - so I don't often post pix. Whatever you're doing, you have good lighting!

I can anti-enable. Runner looked sort of murky on me…the color wasn't very vibrant. It was an easy pass when I tried it on. I much prefer Living Legend - that one is more jewel-toned and also with more purple/plum undertones and less plain old black making it deep. On the other hand, I bet Runner would look brighter on you than it did on me….decisions decisions hehe.
Gunner is SO purple, very blue purple. Instigator is more of a dark wine color. Instigator is also quite a bit darker. They're totally different animals.


Quote: Originally Posted by erine1881


Yes yes!!!
I'm gonna say so!
yes.gif



It doesn't.
Thanks ladies!! Justifies my purchase
greengrin.gif
 

dcarrington

Well-known member
I am wondering if Gunner is a close dupe for the defunked DGAF. Did anyone buy the recent DGAF and is able to compare the two?
 

elegant-one

Well-known member
Just gt my Runner
love.gif
It's SOOOO sexy beautiful on! It was smooth too, & did not go on patchy at all. The shade has a beautiful burgundy depth to it & I think it's different enough from others in that range.
 

Vandekamp

Well-known member
Just gt my Runner
love.gif
It's SOOOO sexy beautiful on! It was smooth too, & did not go on patchy at all. The shade has a beautiful burgundy depth to it & I think it's different enough from others in that range.
What shade does it remind you of? Mine will be here tomorrow. I am so glad you loved it. Between Stunner and Runner which one do you like best.
 

elegant-one

Well-known member
What shade does it remind you of? Mine will be here tomorrow. I am so glad you loved it. Between Stunner and Runner which one do you like best.
Runner! Its just sexy looking LOL! Umm, I don't know...its a complicated purple/aubergine/burgundy shade.

Runner - left, Nars Bette - right

Its much deeper on the lips than my arm
eyelove.gif







 

SassyWonder

Well-known member
After saying I was skipping this collection for months I ended up orordering all 3 with a Gunner bu and I cant wait for them to get here. Definitely spoiled by the shipping codes this feels like an eternity!
 

Vandekamp

Well-known member
After saying I was skipping this collection for months I ended up orordering all 3 with a Gunner bu and I cant wait for them to get here. Definitely spoiled by the shipping codes this feels like an eternity!
Don't feel bad. I said the same thing and I got Runner and Stunner.
lolz.gif
. We can thank Candy and Elegant One for that.
 

AnastasiaRuth

Well-known member
I'm not sure who started that Kinky was a dupe for Stunner, but they either don't know color or they have bad lighting. Honestly, I NEVER believe the whole dupe thing. I can tell the color difference & the shades always look different on me than what someone says is a dupe. You can see below that they are nothing alike :eek:hboy: Stunner is a fuchsia based red. Its beautiful on! Kinky - left, Stunner - right  
I agree with u 100 percent I found that most dupes are not really exact dupes Stunner Is stunningggg
Yeah, thats why you cant listen to everybody. You'll have to see for yourself/get swatches! Sidenote: Gunner is everything I wanted it to be! Just got it in today and it looks great!!
 
Top