Alright, I threw this mascara on as soon as I got up (this afternoon LOL). I have to say that I really like it. I can't compare it to other Mac mascara's because I've never tried one before. There was no clumping, flaking, and it didn't stay wet (ever had that problem? It's gross).
Now the bad news: That big a$$ wand! mac, you have a winning formula, why include a brush big enough for King Kong's lashes? I got mascara on my lid and you know that's a tragedy when wearing shadow. I am good at applying mascara, it takes me 2 seconds and I never get mascara on my lid. Fault lies with this brush. So I have to take more time to not get it on my lid when I do wear shadow. That is the only negative.
Here are pics of both eyes. I am also wearing the Chromographic Pencil. I'll see how both wear throughout the day. (For reference, I have long, semi straight lashes that already have enough volume. What I look for is curl in my mascara. I only applied it to the upper lash, never the bottom.)