MAC Pret a Papier Discussion

AudreyNicole

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by coachkitten
I saw this collection today and I was actually more impressed than I thought I would be. Gazette grey totally stood out to me when I saw the display. It is an army greenish/gray with golden sparkle. Very pretty in the pot but swatched a bit chalky which was a disappointment. I loved loved loved tissue weight eye shadow. It is going to make a great highlight and it does look like a lighter version of rice paper. More white than gold.

I also loved Instant Chic blush. It is really soft and pigmented. I don't normally go for peach shades but it was just too pretty on and really brightened up my face.


Gahhh, Tissueweight is creeping onto my list. Sounds like Gazette Grey is a "swatch in person" shadow, and you just sold me on Instant Chic! I am excited to see everything!!
smiles.gif
 

shontay07108

Well-known member
dothewave.gif


Awww snap, y'all. I went to Mac pro earlier today and guess what I saw/ravaged/bought??? Yes. As soon as I stepped off the elevator and into the doorway I let out an audible...I don't know what to call it. I think it's a sound only a farm animal makes. Anyway, here are my purchases/impressions.

I bought:
Coral Crepe paint pot. Can we say AMAZING??? Truly gorgeous and delicious. It's not coppery at all. It's like a cousin of expensive pink and some other color that escaped me. It's a beautiful coral and I can't wait to wear it not only with other shadows, but completely alone.

Memorabilia shadow. I thought I was over purple. I didn't expect to be impressed by this and if memory serves me correctly, this is a repromote that didn't get much love on makeupalley. When I swatched it, though, I fell for it completely. I can see this with so many looks. It seems out of place in this collection, but it's a nice pop piece.

Made to Order lipstick. Gorgeous, creamy, shiny. All the good stuff. It's a lustre and I love lustres. This is truly a gorgeous coral and it screams summer to me. Especially awesome on girls with my coloring.

Fold and Tuck lipglass. Fall on the floor gorgeous all on it's own. A great compliment to MtO lipstick. I put them together and was blown away. I don't usually layer lippies, but I will have to do so with these occassionally.

Instant Chic blush. Ladies, do yourself a favor and get this! It makes me feel less stupid about missing Ripe Peach. I think this is better. I think this is better than Gina and Gilda by Nars. So pretty, so light, so face brightening I may wear this damn thing every day. Backup worthy.

What I didn't get:
Garb blush. Completely dead on my skin. I had flashbacks to The Perfect Cheek. *shudders*

Groundwork paint pot. Just not interested. The color of Coral Crepe made me even think of buying a paint pot.

Archetype lipstick. It's ok. Not very pigmented, but I guess it can add to other lip products when layered, but it's not worth it for me personally.

Dressmaker, Dressmaker. Again, really pretty, but not for my pigmented lips. It came off as kinda milky and just off on my coloring. Rock this pale girls.

C-Thru lipglass. Hell to the no. I know lots of people love this, but I don't get it. Milky and harsh. Ick.

Originality polish. Very pretty, but not a color I like to see on myself. I prefer brights and I'm leaning away from shimmery/frosty polishes.

Cut to Fit shadow. Reminds me of Coppering and Antiqued. Not a bad color, but on me I feel it makes me look like I have a rash. The color is too coppery/bronzey for me.

What I'm going back for:
Tissue Wait: Very pretty. It's not really outstanding or unique, but who can turn down a pretty color and nice finish like that? Pret A Papier lipglass: hotness. I tried not to go completely broke, so I left it behind. It will be mine, though. Paper Bag polish: Beautiful. It has a great texture and takes maybe 2 coats. Very subtle and sophisticated color. Kraft: Oh so pretty. I need it. Just had to leave it behind for budget reasons.

Jury is out on:
Gazette Grey: The texture seemed nice enough but it has some glitter/shimmer in it and I see that falling everywhere. It's nice, but I don't NEED it. Knowing me, though I will get it eventually.


Sorry about the long post. Just hope it helps. Swatches are coming.
yes.gif
 

shontay07108

Well-known member
Products

s640x480


Top: Made to Order lipstick, Memorabilia shadow
Bottom: Fold and Tuck lipglass, Coral Crepe paint pot, Instant Chic blush

s640x480


A little closer

s640x480
 

AudreyNicole

Well-known member
Shontay, everything looks lovely on you! I sure hope it doesn't look that good on me, cause I was planning to haul very small on this collection!!
 

sapnap

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by shontay07108
Products

s640x480


Top: Made to Order lipstick, Memorabilia shadow
Bottom: Fold and Tuck lipglass, Coral Crepe paint pot, Instant Chic blush

s640x480


A little closer

s640x480



shontay love ya for ur review and swatches!! am gonna get ething u got except for maybe the purple e/s
 

shontay07108

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by AudreyNicole
Shontay, everything looks lovely on you! I sure hope it doesn't look that good on me, cause I was planning to haul very small on this collection!!

Lol Audrey! Thanks. I really love this collection. I just knew I would. This, in my mind, is the real follow up to Spring Forecast. Mac was just playing games with the other stuff.

Quote:
Originally Posted by sapnap
shontay love ya for ur review and swatches!! am gonna get ething u got except for maybe the purple e/s

Thanks sapnap. Everything is just gorgeous. I do hope to take a break from purple shadows for a long time after this, though.
yes.gif
I'm all purpled out.
shockt.gif
 

Nelly711

Well-known member
Awesome review, Shontay! I only planned on getting a few items from this collection and now you got me thinking about things that I wasn't even interested in. :)
 

shontay07108

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nelly711
Awesome review, Shontay! I only planned on getting a few items from this collection and now you got me thinking about things that I wasn't even interested in. :)

Which items are you interested in now?
 

Nelly711

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by shontay07108
Which items are you interested in now?

Memorabilia e/s (I have way too many purples and this one looks very pretty), coral crepe paint pot and the two lippies that you bought along with that blush. I gotta tell myself that I don't need all of this stuff lol. I only planned on getting gazette grey e/s and the other lipglass
 

GlamYOURUs

Well-known member
My list:

Coral Crepe p/p
Instant Chic Blush
NC30/NW25 Pencil
Memorabilia e/s
Bamboo e/s

will decide when I see them all though next week!
 

miss_primer

Well-known member
I totally thought this collection was a pass. Shontay, your review and swatches sold me on Instant Chic Blush. I have to at least check this blush out. I can't let this one pass me bye. (ie. Ripe Peach)
 

DonnaN

Well-known member
Thanks to Shontay's reviews & pics, I think I'm gonna have to swatch a LOT!!

Thank you MAC goddesses for the Coral Crepe paint pot.....it's HEAVEN in a jar!!!
th_worship.gif
 

InspiredBlue

Well-known member
Thanks for the review Shontay. I've been saying pass, boring, on to the next all this time, but everything looks great on you
drools.gif
 

sss215

Well-known member
Quote:
Originally Posted by shontay07108
dothewave.gif


Awww snap, y'all. I went to Mac pro earlier today and guess what I saw/ravaged/bought??? Yes. As soon as I stepped off the elevator and into the doorway I let out an audible...I don't know what to call it. I think it's a sound only a farm animal makes. Anyway, here are my purchases/impressions.

I bought:
Coral Crepe paint pot. Can we say AMAZING??? Truly gorgeous and delicious. It's not coppery at all. It's like a cousin of expensive pink and some other color that escaped me. It's a beautiful coral and I can't wait to wear it not only with other shadows, but completely alone.

Memorabilia shadow. I thought I was over purple. I didn't expect to be impressed by this and if memory serves me correctly, this is a repromote that didn't get much love on makeupalley. When I swatched it, though, I fell for it completely. I can see this with so many looks. It seems out of place in this collection, but it's a nice pop piece.

Made to Order lipstick. Gorgeous, creamy, shiny. All the good stuff. It's a lustre and I love lustres. This is truly a gorgeous coral and it screams summer to me. Especially awesome on girls with my coloring.

Fold and Tuck lipglass. Fall on the floor gorgeous all on it's own. A great compliment to MtO lipstick. I put them together and was blown away. I don't usually layer lippies, but I will have to do so with these occassionally.

Instant Chic blush. Ladies, do yourself a favor and get this! It makes me feel less stupid about missing Ripe Peach. I think this is better. I think this is better than Gina and Gilda by Nars. So pretty, so light, so face brightening I may wear this damn thing every day. Backup worthy.

What I didn't get:
Garb blush. Completely dead on my skin. I had flashbacks to The Perfect Cheek. *shudders*

Groundwork paint pot. Just not interested. The color of Coral Crepe made me even think of buying a paint pot.

Archetype lipstick. It's ok. Not very pigmented, but I guess it can add to other lip products when layered, but it's not worth it for me personally.

Dressmaker, Dressmaker. Again, really pretty, but not for my pigmented lips. It came off as kinda milky and just off on my coloring. Rock this pale girls.

C-Thru lipglass. Hell to the no. I know lots of people love this, but I don't get it. Milky and harsh. Ick.

Originality polish. Very pretty, but not a color I like to see on myself. I prefer brights and I'm leaning away from shimmery/frosty polishes.

Cut to Fit shadow. Reminds me of Coppering and Antiqued. Not a bad color, but on me I feel it makes me look like I have a rash. The color is too coppery/bronzey for me.

What I'm going back for:
Tissue Wait: Very pretty. It's not really outstanding or unique, but who can turn down a pretty color and nice finish like that? Pret A Papier lipglass: hotness. I tried not to go completely broke, so I left it behind. It will be mine, though. Paper Bag polish: Beautiful. It has a great texture and takes maybe 2 coats. Very subtle and sophisticated color. Kraft: Oh so pretty. I need it. Just had to leave it behind for budget reasons.

Jury is out on:
Gazette Grey: The texture seemed nice enough but it has some glitter/shimmer in it and I see that falling everywhere. It's nice, but I don't NEED it. Knowing me, though I will get it eventually.


Sorry about the long post. Just hope it helps. Swatches are coming.
yes.gif



thanks for the review and swatches!!! I know I am going to get the paint pot. and Memorabilia looks good swatched up too. I mean I could use a new purple shadow... just 1 and not a whole quad like in spring forecast. I wonder how memorabilia would look with over the coral crepe paint pot. thanks again!
 

RayannaBanana

Well-known member
Hmm if Instant Chic is anything like Ripe Peach it probably wouldn't work for me. Ripe Peach is too orange for my skintone.
 
Top