Estée Lauder Chocolate #23. I've been using that for at least 12 years! I've had the actual automatic pencil for that long surprisingly lol. The print has long since rubbed off. Luckily the refills haven't been changed so they still fit. It's been my go to lip pencil for tweaking almost any color and making it work for me. That pencil is always in my purse...
As you can see it's almost time for me to pop another refill in! Interestingly, I've never used any other Estée Lauder products and can't begin to tell you how I started using this one (pretty sure it had to be because of someone's mom lol)