OKAY. I saw this yesterday, came home with 3 things.
Tone: Grey Quad: It's gorgeous. I even like the "Deep Truth" blue. It's way more dusty and grey though when I swatched it, so I actually liked it a lot despite the similarities. I think the difference is more obvious IRL. Everything swatched nicely and I KNOW it will get a lot of use this fall. I'm breaking out ALL the fall quads.
Red Full Stop: After the horrors of Costa Chic I didn't want to try this. Sorry girls. It was too similar looking to me and scary.
Hipster: Okay, I said no more dark vampy lips. But this was so pretty on me I had to have it. It's like a lighter frostier Kirsch, so I WOULD love it. You know me. Anyone want swatches?
Faultlessly F/W: I remember not liking Bing on me or the SUPER vampy lip, so I skipped this, didn't want to try it on.
Our Pick: This was HIDEOUS on me. Sorry, I'm WAY too cool toned for this, that's all I have to say. It will definitely work on warm/pink/blue undertone ladies. Unfortunately, I'm yellow-toned and it was WEIRD looking on me. It was like.. gray coffee on my lips. Even the lipglass didn't fix this. Ew. I can't stand it, I wish I didn't try it. HAHAHA. I'm serious, you all think I can pull off any color, but I can't do this one. Any NC girls, WATCH OUT!
New Berry: I liked Hipster without this. So I didn't get it, it's VERY creamy, a bit darker in color than Hipster, so I feel I didn't need it, but it has great color to it. I definitely like this instead of So this Season.
So this Season: I'm not a big fan of purple, sorry girls, I didn't try this on. I don't see the point if I'm not even going to use it.
Runway Fave: This came home with me too, SUCH an interesting color, way taupier than Young Thing, though I love Young Thing as well. Definitely the most unique thing I picked up.
OVERALL: This is a very nice small collection.
It has very unique lippies, while all the colors are not for everyone, I'm sure you'll find ONE unique color in this collection to like. They're all pretty damn unique to me, even Hipster.