I haven't read through every page of this thread, but have we reached a consensus on lipsticks? I swatched/tried all of them on lips yesterday and here's my 2 cents:
Faultlessly F/W- Yes, oh, yes. A deep, dark, cool currant color, a purple/violet shade. I noticed grey undertones and love the amplified formula. I have thinner lips, so I don't often wear a lipstick so dark, but I got it anyway because it is unique and I'm a sucker for that!
Our Pick- Such a weird lipstick! Really a grey/tan/light brown. But with a smooth Satin formula that glides on smoother than Fleshpot. Not for my coloring (NC15), I just looked scary in it, but someone will rock this, I know! Very interesting color. I want to see what other ppl do with it, for sure!
Red Full Stop- Actually the winner for me, oddly, a summery shade of coral but it isn't really coral it's a pink/bright red melted together. Lustre formula stick to lips better than most. I don't know what it is about this particular lipstick, but it feels great on the lips and traces of it will last into tomorrow if you don't properly remove it. Very interesting, bright and fun! I collect MAC coral shades and plan to take pics of most of what I have in that spectrum side by each for comparison.
Hipster- Meh. Dupable, wine colored Frost lipstick. Nothing special.
I ended up buying Red full stop and Faultlessly f/w. Love 'em!