First impressions and swatches! Unfortunately, today is really overcast. :/ It won't clear up all weekend. I took all photos in the window, trying to get as much direct sunlight as possible.
NFP: I was a little disappointed that this wasn't pulling really bright pink like some swatches I've seen! Maybe it's because it's not 100% sunny out?
HC: This pulls more purple-ish on me. I really love this color! However, it looks like a lot of lipsticks I have. Chanel's La romanesque comes to mind, TF's Jack possibly. This is definitely a color I'm drawn to more frequently. It looks close to NFP in the photo, but they're definitely different in person. Especially on the lips!
Cardinal: It's a pretty red. You can tell in the photo it is a little more "yellow" and "warm" than the swatch below which is MM. I have so many reds like this. I've yet to try it on the lips, yet, and see how much it really differs on the lips compared to MM. However, this one took quite a few passes to build up, unlike MM which was one swipe opaque and creamy.
MM: A touch cooler than Cardinal. I'm loving this one more that Cardinal-- possibly from the formula, though. It was much more opaque at first swipe. Smooth and creamy. Definitely dupeable, but a lovely formula and still a lovely shade of red. I'll keep this one and likely return Cardinal if I can't tell much of a difference on the lips. The box was super cute in person... I wish they came in packaging like this!
Top to Bottom: NFP, HC, Cardinal, MM.
Top to Bottom:
NFP, HC.
Top to Bottm:
Cardinal, MM.