NARS + Guy Bourdin - Holiday 2013

MarieMary

Well-known member
Swatches and review of the individual nail polishes:
http://imabeautygeek.com/2013/10/07/mani-monday-nars-guy-bourdin-holiday-color-collection-nail-polish/

Swatches and review of Wishful Thinking Eyeshadow (the blue one):
http://blushingnoir.com/2013/10/nars-wishful-thinking-cinematic-eyeshadow-swatches-review-eotd-guy-bourdin-holiday-2013-2/
 

lenamonster

Well-known member
Temptalia has decided not to review this Nars collection (at least at this time)

http://www.temptalia.com/nars-x-guy-bourdin-gifting-collection-holiday-2013
 

brittbby

Well-known member
I want the crime of passion set! Look perfect for traveling!! Lots of crazy comments on T's post. Disappointed she won't be reviewing them, as I appreciate her swatches. Oh well, I will still be purchasing items!
 

LavenderPearl

Well-known member
This article linked from Temptalia about Guy made me very uncomfortable: http://www.utata.org/sundaysalon/guy-bourdin/ At this point, I think I'll be skipping this collection. Oh well, there are still plenty of items in the permanent collection I need to buy!
I think I agree with you. Even before I read this, the imagery used on the boxes for the collection were really turning me off. Now I'm especially disturbed.
 

katred

Specktra Bestie
I'm actually a little surprised that it's only in looking at his history that people have noticed the inclination towards violence. I got a very dark impression from some of the images from this collection. That said, I would treat that Utata article with a great deal of caution. It makes some pretty disturbing claims about the artist as a person, but doesn't cite any sources, so it's very difficult to verify what's being said.

I'm also surprised that Temptalia sort of "buried" her decision. Usually, she bumps a thread when she edits it. Or perhaps I just missed that- I was traveling this weekend.
 

elkaknits

Well-known member
I don't think it would make a difference if she does change her mind and reviews it.... she is obviously critical of the collection. Personally I think it is ridiculous. This is not to say that violence against woman isn't a real issue but I think boycotting something because it is based on somebody else's work and that somebody else may have been callous... Fact is the 80's high fashion magazines were, and still are for that matter, 'kink friendly' and if you look at the life of Gia for example she was supposedly strung out on heroin and looked dead in half her pictures. Why would a fashion photographer have more respect for the health of a model than she herself has? Not saying she was photographed by him but from what I have read of famous models from 60s through early 80s {eddie and gia} they were not exactly present. If you are photographing girls who are passed out or on drugs all the time then being all here honey let me wait for you to be conscious doesn't make much sense to me.

I think it is sad that his wife and girlfriends were also troubled. I used to work for a very wealthy family in NY and they had very famous people at their parties {models, politicians, actors} and I can assure you that even into the 90s the drug culture and casual sex were still very much the thing. I was a nanny and the kids were so messed up needing counseling and I wouldn't be surprised if I read in some rag that they had both drug problems but made poor romantic choices. I would assume he met his girlfriends the way most men meet their girlfriends~ through work or socializing with friends who would have been part of that culture. I would assume they had drug problems and maybe his frustration with them caused him to lock them in or keep them off the phone so they couldn't be getting drugs. Or maybe his frustration with how a drug problem had him look down on the women he worked with. All supposition but the article was also supposition or a quote or two taken out of context.

I cannot believe people are talking about boycotting Nars. Pshaw. I certainly am not going to judge Nars for saying hey this guy's images influenced me into going into makeup and I want to pay homage to those images. Nobody had this flap over Warhol doing a lot of male nudes and having his films open in gay porn theatres. Are we saying it is okay to fetishize men but not to fetishize women? He photographed and filmed his 'friends' in the middle of orgies and distributed it as art... wiki on the factory says:
Nudity, graphic sexuality, drug use, same-sex relations and transgender characters appear in some form in almost all of his work filmed at the Silver Factory. Considered socially unacceptable, even appalling at the time, theaters showing his underground films were sometimes raided and the staff arrested for obscenity.
However, by making the films, Warhol created a sexually lenient environment at the Factory for the happenings that they staged, such as fake drag weddings, porn theater rentals, and vulgar plays. A large amount of free love took place in the scene, as sexuality in the 1960s was becoming more open. Sex was practically a must for anyone hanging around, and was encouraged by Warhol, who used footage of sexual acts between his friends in his work.
Also part of 'the scene' at the Factory were famous drag queens such as Holly Woodlawn and Jackie Curtis, and the transgendered Candy Darling. As an artist, Andy Warhol frequently used these women and other sexual non-conformists in his films, plays, and on-goings.
Because of the constant drug use and the presence of sexually liberal artists and radicals, drugged orgies were a frequent happening at the Factory. Andy met Ondine at an orgy in 1962.

Seriously, and I am not trying to say it was okay, if it is true, but I would have to boycott every single makeup and fashion house if I were going by they did a sexually degrading image or tested on animals way back in the 60s. Heck there are people that consider high heels a torture of women that thows their back out of wack and ruins their tendons and what not. There are people that consider a short skirt or low cut blouse degrading to women. And make-up is some form of harlotry. Or maybe it is because I live in the bible belt where wearing makeup can be seen as suspicious by some. I even have a friend who considers wearing her hair down sinful. I deal enough with that madness that I am not looking at what may or may not have been happening 50 yrs ago 0.o
 

brittbby

Well-known member
Whatever happened in his personal life isn't really my business, his art is what NARS is using and I'm ok with art being out there and pushing the boundaries. Everybody has to form their own opinions on what they will buy and why, just voicing mine! It's the same thing with everything music, movies, any art form really. I feel disappointed that T didn't review them because as a makeup blog, I feel that she should take an unbiased stance and swatch any samples they send her. Now if she has to go out and buy them is a different story... Then she can use her own personal choice to decide whether to support NARS and their collaboration or not.
 

katred

Specktra Bestie
Here's a peek at Coeur Battant, including swatches applied with different blush brushes:

http://www.thenonblonde.com/2013/10/nars-coeur-battant-blush-guy-bourdin.html
 

MarieMary

Well-known member
Here's a peek at Coeur Battant, including swatches applied with different blush brushes:

http://www.thenonblonde.com/2013/10/nars-coeur-battant-blush-guy-bourdin.html
Gorgeous, it looks almost blindingly neon. I like that she used different blush brushes, that's very nice of her, and helpful!
 

LiliV

Well-known member
I don't have any problem with Bourdin and I love the colors for this collection! I'm definitely sold on the blush
love.gif
 

kimibos

Well-known member
Drama here too! i was trying to get away from the mac holiday collection prices!

i want the Red Lips Bag, and the peachy blush. its going to be my 1st regular size nars blush.
 

kimibos

Well-known member
I don't have any problem with Bourdin and I love the colors for this collection! I'm definitely sold on the blush
love.gif
same here! they did Warhol last year, and he was kind of creepy too. i didnt see any blogger complaining. see what happens when they have a cult following them. makes them think they are a big deal.
Is not like one cares about the Review's and "Grades", all we want is swatches!

Which Blush are you getting????
 

elkaknits

Well-known member
Here's a peek at Coeur Battant, including swatches applied with different blush brushes:

http://www.thenonblonde.com/2013/10/nars-coeur-battant-blush-guy-bourdin.html
That is beautiful Katred. I was planning on skipping the blush {because I have so much blush and I have yet to finish a single one in decades} but now I will get it. I was considering Exhibit A for a red flush but unsure about it. I think all 3 just hopped into my cart. I also want the palette with new blush and highlighter. This whole collex with the exception of eyeshadows has me drooling. I just do a nude eye so although I can do a plum or pinkish shell type of colors I won't be doing blue and orange and all that other out there stuff.

I am so excited about this and the Dior diorifics coming out this holiday season. And I am sorry if my earlier post offended anybody. I certainly respect anybody's right to boycott whatever they please. After all I am on a hopefully short Estee Lauder and co boycott and so I am missing the holiday price drama llama mentioned above. I am tempted to peek just to see what the flap is about! :">
 

LiliV

Well-known member
same here! they did Warhol last year, and he was kind of creepy too. i didnt see any blogger complaining. see what happens when they have a cult following them. makes them think they are a big deal.  Is not like one cares about the Review's and "Grades", all we want is swatches!  Which Blush are you getting????
Coeur Battant for me! I don't have anything like it
 

LiliV

Well-known member
CB looks Gorgeous but im kind of afraid of it, and Exhibit A. i have yachiyo brush but still, they look crazy pigmented and bright. im so heavy handed.
blush-anim-cl.gif
I don't have a lot of super dark blushes because I'm really pale, but I love bold blush colors in the fall and winter, I think Coeur Battant will be so pretty!
 
Top