the Smudge Sticks are amazing!
- Thread starter Ellen1
- Start date
FiestyFemme
Well-known member
That's good to hear! I got the purple one (Purple Tang) about a month ago, but I'm trying to use up another liner so I haven't used it yet. I can't wait though! I'm afraid I'm going to want them all.
kimmietrinh
Well-known member
I still have 5 of the smudge pots! Are they better than the pots? The pots smudge on my lash line.
SmokeSignal16
Well-known member
Yeah I bought all of these they are frickin awesome!!! Once they set after like 3 seconds they do not budge!
Mabelle
Well-known member
We got a training with Stila for the new products, and the liners are CRAZY!!!
I love all the colours (the peacock, the black, the green! then brown the gold!!) they smudge so nicely and then set like no ones buissness.
Plus they are waterline safe. woooottt. This is def. going to replace feline as my waterline colour
I love all the colours (the peacock, the black, the green! then brown the gold!!) they smudge so nicely and then set like no ones buissness.
Plus they are waterline safe. woooottt. This is def. going to replace feline as my waterline colour
BadBadGirl
Well-known member
Quote:
OH EM GEE- is the black one almost as dark as Feline?
I am so on these!
Originally Posted by Mabelle
We got a training with Stila for the new products, and the liners are CRAZY!!! I love all the colours (the peacock, the black, the green! then brown the gold!!) they smudge so nicely and then set like no ones buissness. Plus they are waterline safe. woooottt. This is def. going to replace feline as my waterline colour |
OH EM GEE- is the black one almost as dark as Feline?
I am so on these!
SmokeSignal16
Well-known member
Has anyone had luck on these staying on their waterline? Because I am not having much luck.. They stay perfectly fine on upper and lower lashlines for me but my waterline not so much.
Mabelle
Well-known member
I used Lionfish (the brownish) on my waterline with no problems. It stayed all day, and was very pigmented.
I wore Moray on my lid (the green). I put both on around 8:30 am, and they only started to fade around 11 pm. When i went to bed at 3 am, they were still on. I woke up this morning (forgot to wash my face!) and again, there was still some colour kickin around.
I saw my friend using stingray (the black) on her waterline, and it was SO black. As black as feline for sure!
Edited to add: I forgot to mention, when i wear eyeliner without a base/shadow, i usually get that ugly ring of colour just above my crease, where when my eye is open, then line rubs off/travels due to oils. Not with these babies!!!!
I wore Moray on my lid (the green). I put both on around 8:30 am, and they only started to fade around 11 pm. When i went to bed at 3 am, they were still on. I woke up this morning (forgot to wash my face!) and again, there was still some colour kickin around.
I saw my friend using stingray (the black) on her waterline, and it was SO black. As black as feline for sure!
Edited to add: I forgot to mention, when i wear eyeliner without a base/shadow, i usually get that ugly ring of colour just above my crease, where when my eye is open, then line rubs off/travels due to oils. Not with these babies!!!!
BadBadGirl
Well-known member
^Cool! I was going to buy some Milani black liner but I'll try this instead to see how it works for me. I'll report back in a few days.
FiestyFemme
Well-known member
I finally wore Purple Tang yesterday, and it lasted all day in our extreme heat & humidity. I removed my makeup with an oil-based cleanser, and I'm still seeing traces of the liner in my lashline this morning. It's strong stuff, but I like it! I want Koi, Silver Dollar, and Stingray next... but I still want them all (like I knew I would, haha!).
BadBadGirl
Well-known member
o m g! I thought I wanted the black first, but now I'm not so sure....
Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliners (swatches) ~ *A Brilliant Brunette*
Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliners (swatches) ~ *A Brilliant Brunette*
SmokeSignal16
Well-known member
I like these on my top and bottom lashlines but no matter what it does not last on my waterline at all! Unless I layer another pencil like Onxy kajal is the only way it'll stay.
SmokeSignal16
Well-known member
I know I'm kind of sad it doesn't stay on by itself, but it works fine and stays for hours when I layer Stila's Black Onyx kajal on top so no worries! Same with Feline from MAC, I have to layer Stila's Black Onyx on top of that for it to stay too.
Courtney <3
Well-known member
are these anything like the urban decay 24/7 liners?
Ms_Slick
Well-known member
I have five out of the eight colors (both blues, purple, brown, and green) and I still want the silver and the gold. I like these better than the UD 24/7 liners. They both have excellent staying power, I just prefer the retractable applicator instead of having to constantly sharpen a pencil. Stila, we need more colors! I absolutely need a gunmetal grey similiar to gunmetal from UD. These are also great for layering! I use the peacock under the blue satin to get a nice smoky blue teal.
