I used Lionfish (the brownish) on my waterline with no problems. It stayed all day, and was very pigmented.
I wore Moray on my lid (the green). I put both on around 8:30 am, and they only started to fade around 11 pm. When i went to bed at 3 am, they were still on. I woke up this morning (forgot to wash my face!) and again, there was still some colour kickin around.
I saw my friend using stingray (the black) on her waterline, and it was SO black. As black as feline for sure!
Edited to add: I forgot to mention, when i wear eyeliner without a base/shadow, i usually get that ugly ring of colour just above my crease, where when my eye is open, then line rubs off/travels due to oils. Not with these babies!!!!