Hmmm oh wow. I wish I could swatch in person but I won't be near a TF counter until thanksgiving. It's a pretty color and some of the pictures / swatches on here made it look stunning. I don't know how I feel about ordering it. I'm thinking of waiting until the ABH self-made palette appears on nordies and spring for both at the same time. I could always return thanks to nordstroms great return policy. You look beautiful as always, and thanks for the honest review!!Both all over lid because cream alone was too patchy. I've tried fingers and a Sephora Pro concealer brush. Maybe a different primer and/or different tools would make it easier to use. Others may not have same issues I have.