Vanilla or Brule?

[kelly2509t]

If you could only own one of these which one would it be?

I can't decide help me

 

[Purple]

I loooove Brule, it's my HG eyeshadow, highlighter, my everyday shadow.
I'm NC30 for reference.

 

[Almond_Eyed]

I use Vanilla, but I'm considering getting Brule. If you swatch them side by side Vanilla looks really white, Brule is a more creamy shade.

 

[BeccalovesMAC]

Brule. I didnt like vanilla

 

[Lyssah]

I'm n15 and vanilla is too white for me. I recommend Brule.

 

[xxManBeaterxx]

I use Brule all over the lid and vanilla as a brow highlight. Vanilla can look a little bit chalky on the lid.

 

[thiscarmen]

Brule all the way! Lid colour and highlight.
Vanilla is too white on me sometimes.

NC35 by the way.

 

[fallenang3l211]

brule all the way! i have vanilla and i barely touch it - goes on chalky and too white for me sometimes, too. brule goes with almost every es i have imo. i usually do an all over wash of brule and then apply my other es for easy blending.

 

[kelly2509t]

Thanks everyone! Sounds like Brule it is

 

[Shadowy Lady]

I'd say either Brule or even better get Blanc Type. Pretty much same colour as Brule but better texture

 

[Susanne]

I LOVE Vanilla. It is my MOST used e/s from MAC ever. It is the perfect highlight colour all year long:

I am NW 20 in winter, NC 25 in spring and fall and NC 30 in summer.

Get Vanilla!!

 

[ThePowderPuff]

Depends on what you're looking for. I don't have vanilla but it looks whiter to me.

I have brule but I'm not very fond of it. It dissapears COMPLETELY on my nc 25 skin. You can't see it at all.

 

[blondie711]

I agree with Katjamo, Brule just disappears on me. I'm nw20-25. I want it to work, it just doesn't. I like Blanc type or Vanilla.

 

[ThePowderPuff]

Quote:

Originally Posted by blondie711 I agree with Katjamo, Brule just disappears on me. I'm nw20-25. I want it to work, it just doesn't. I like Blanc type or Vanilla.

I love Blanc Type to. It's one of my favorites. I love Matte2.

 

[FiestyFemme]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Susanne I LOVE Vanilla. It is my MOST used e/s from MAC ever. It is the perfect highlight colour all year long: I am NW 20 in winter, NC 25 in spring and fall and NC 30 in summer. Get Vanilla!!

Agreed! I LOVE Vanilla. I hardly ever touch Brule. I'm an NC 15/20 for reference.

 

[kelly2509t]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Katjamo Depends on what you're looking for. I don't have vanilla but it looks whiter to me. I have brule but I'm not very fond of it. It dissapears COMPLETELY on my nc 25 skin. You can't see it at all.

I'm wanting to use it for a brow bone highlight and for my tear duct area. Thanks for the rec though everyone

 

[January]

LOVE Vanilla... I'm an NW15/20 and I just seen a tiny little pan in my Vanilla the other day. Love it

 

[ThePowderPuff]

Quote:

Originally Posted by kelly2509t I'm wanting to use it for a brow bone highlight and for my tear duct area. Thanks for the rec though everyone

Seriously if you're NC25 like me, you will not get any highlighting from Brulé at all. It's basically just skincolour.

 

[kelly2509t]

I'm not sure what I am in terms of MAC NC/NW (never been colour matched, must do that one day!) But I'm pretty pale as you can see from my avatar. The foundation shade I use is ivory so pretty pale

I've been looking at Blanc Type and liking the look of that too

 

[January]

I'm pale too, and I love Blanc Typed, I think it's a must have