Nightmoth + Subverted = try it!!!!! Sounds counterintuitive, but it's great. Honestly, I don't use liner with any of these much, since their texture is so light, even though the color and frost appears dense. If you want something closer to a perfect match, there's Bittersweet Pro Longwear lip pencil. Actually, quite a few of the PLWs would be good underneath or just to line - stuff like Morning Coffee, Staunchly Stylish or even Absolutely It, since they've got lots of brown in them for MLBB type colors. Honestly, I don't think it's always the best choice to use a lip liner as dark as a really dark lipstick - it often looks nicer to use something something in between the lipstick color and your skin or lip color, to act as a soft transitional edge. You'll still get the effect of a nice sharp edge, without a pasted-on clown lips effect. You can use colors like these underneath or afterwards, right on top, around the edges, then blended in (I learned this trick from my MAU friends and at this point, I use it even more than lining underneath.)
Also, as far as the light lid + black liner look, I keep trying to find ways to make it work for me. Using a color just a very tiny bit darker than my skin tone in the crease above the light color is imperative. Also, it usually looks better if I've primed my lids really well, so they're as smooth as possible. Using a light color that's a little sheerer helps too. Finally, I usually have to switch to a finer liner brush, since I don't have a ton of lid real estate, or use liquid liner rather than gel - then, I need to do a liner shape that makes my eyes more rounded than my usual application, which leans almond shaped. Basically all these steps are to make my lids and eyes as "young" looking as possible, since this is a look that is definitely for a youthful look and style. I've practiced this sooooo much, since I like this type of look, but need to find a good balance so it doesn't look like I'm trying too hard.