Sorry, but they are different :haha:. Both of those are good duos. I own them both. Actually, looking at all four shades, they are completely different from one another. Saffron is my personal fave even though I have yet to use it

hboy:. Like I said, Saffron is a deep, matte, kinda rusty orange. Like a Rule/Orange shadow baby. Paparazz-She is a shimmery orange kinda like a cousin of Amberlights. The orange from Balthazar is a soft, muted, slightly shimmery orange, but more on the gold side. Kinda like an orange Goldmine. The orange from Mediteranee is the boldest, more peachy orange with shimmer. All are worth having, I think. Left to Right: Saffron, Paparazz-She, Balthazar, Mediteranee