Ok, guys I can't properly capture the colors in pictures. Weird, because I never had this problem before. Either coral is tricky, I've lost my photo mojo or I need a new camera(me thinks I need a new camera). I swatched Cyndi, Exxhibitionist, Hibiscus and Toxic Tale. Good news: If you have Exxhibitionist, don't throw yourself off a cliff if you can't get hibiscus. That is, unless you're a major coral freak like me. They are close. What separates them is the formula and there is a color difference that I can't quite put my finger on. It's actually making my head hurt. Staring at similar colors and trying to explain them makes me think I need to brush up on my colors. Hibiscus might be more...pink or is it orange? I'm thinking orange. There is a difference, but it is slight, so don't cry. If anything, just be mad that Mac has screwed over the masses by not having enough product. They know how popular corals have been in the past year. I'm glad I got Hibiscus because I prefer Mac lipsticks over any of their lip products. Bad news: If you don't have Exxhibitionist, then you may want to try your best to track down Hibiscus. Cyndi doesn't compare. It's more red, it's less opaque(obviously). Nowhere near as bold. Toxic Tale is too bold. It's a satin. It takes work for most of us to wear. I know I need to wear it with Cherry liner to keep from looking like a demented hobo(still love it, though). Also, it's dry for me so I need to make sure my lips are at their best because this lipstick will show every flaw. So, hope that helps.