I think I managed to cut down my list.
Getting Later because it's effing gorgeous (it looks even better than my beloved Young Punk in swatches!) and If It Sparkles... because I think it'd be pretty as a wash or just to add a little shimmer to other looks. Passing on Partylicious because it's similar to Cool Heat, I never use pigments, and I never use teals! I'm just bad at them, I guess.
For DGC, I'm definitely getting If It's Pink. Not gettin Sparkilicious (too light for me, won't show up on my pigmented lips). Undecided on I.Want.Candy. Leaning toward no right now because it looks like work, but yes because it's unique and I might be kicking myself later if I don't get it...
I'm skipping So Rich So Pretty (even though I LOVE the name) because it's too red-toned for me. Definitely getting Morning.After. (LOVE this color in the nail swatches I've seen.) I think I'm getting Military as well - I don't have any matte polishes, and I like the glitter + matte look of this one.
So... that's better than getting everything in this collection like I was originally thinking!