MAC by Request (April 1,2014)
- Thread starter Addict4MAC
- Start date
ARmakeupjunkie
Well-known member
I have them both. I think they are both good reds but, Glam has been my favorite red since I first discovered it back around 06. I think it looks better than Ronnie Red but, not sure how close they are. If I have time I will try to do a swatch and post it for you. That may not be until much later tonight.
OctoberViolet
Well-known member
I'm glad Pink Poodle is in the lead. That's my favorite. I'm excited for Rozz also. I still wish MAC would have brought back older shades. Fingers crossed they will in the near future.
Yesterday, Rozz wasn't in the top three, I'm pretty happy it's up on the top 3 today!
Denae78
Well-known member
If you have a chance, I'd appreciate it. I have RR and love it, Glam looks like something I might NEED though
LavenderPearl
Well-known member
Hoop is in the lead? Lol, what? o_o Also, PiPo is listed as a Frost, but T lists it as a glaze... An error, do you think? And what do we think about the glaze finish? I've never tried one.
hoshiakari_
Well-known member
I voted for Rozz yesterday and I voted for Tomango today. I really hope it makes it to the top three! The only eyeshadow that kinda catches my interest is Butterscotch (and I do like the name, it makes me want something sweet
) but other than that, I find the shadows to be blah. I quite agree that this is how By Request should be done, by offering shades that haven't been repromoted in the last year or so... but that's just me.
OctoberViolet
Well-known member
Oh my. How embarrassing.
I didn't read the poll right. Pink Poodle isn't in the lead. It's in second place. I want Pink Poodle darn it!
KMQE716
Well-known member
the description of Glam does not match the color lol. if it looks like that though i would want it to win. not if it looks like the description.
Yesterday, Rozz wasn't in the top three, I'm pretty happy it's up on the top 3 today!
I don't know how i feel about Pink Poodle in the lead.
KMQE716
Well-known member
When i had the older version it was a glaze...maybe they are updating it's finish to that now *scratches head*
ARmakeupjunkie
Well-known member
I will never understand the love for colors like Hoop and Flavour.
LavenderPearl
Well-known member
I'm still like "How did this happen?!" with seeing Hoop in first place. I don't get it, but I am trying. Just like I love brights, some people like more muted shades and I can't fault them for it... except if they're kicking my favorites out of the top three lol >>
ahellokittybaby
Well-known member
I really don't understand why Hoop and Flavour are so high up in the ranking. I really don't want the neutrals moving all the bolder colors out of the running.
Lipstickjunkii
Well-known member
I'm really surprised to see Tomango at the damn near bottom.
Ana A
Well-known member
After you submit your vote it takes you to the latest vote count. Im not sure if I'm able to see it on my phone though, I've been doing it on my laptop.
KrystalAnne
Well-known member
I might be alone on this, but I actually like the way Hoop looks. To be totally honest, I'm not head-over-heels with any of these shades though. That's not to say I won't get any. But I'd rather get the Retro Mattes.
ladyarwen
Well-known member
I really like Hoop too! It reminds me of Haute Altitude.
Ana A
Well-known member
You're not alone Hoop its a nice color and if it were part of any other collection I'll be ordering it, I just dont find it worthy of Mac by "request"
KrystalAnne
Well-known member
It sort of reminds me of HA, too. But I'm hoping it's a bit different. Although I do like HA, it's veryyy similar to my natural lip color, so maybe slightly brighter than HA would be good for me.
Addict4MAC
Well-known member
I voted for it today because of luvlydee's post about it being a good highlight for medium/darker skin tones. So now I'm intrigued.
