MAC by Request (April 1,2014)

BriarRose

Well-known member
Oh noo I just voted for it an hour ago! I hope it changes..its a perfect colour for a green smokey eye. There are so many black/grey/neutral shadows already:(
Not to mention taupe.

It seems like a taupe eyeshadow comes out every time I turn around, or maybe that is just my imagination.

Fiction is my favorite of the ES as well.
 

MACina

Well-known member
Oh yes, those are all beautiful
eyelove.gif

Thank you! :)

Pink Poodle, Richer Lusher, and Double Dare are my favorite glosses in the perm line, so naturally I want the lipstick to go with the lipgloss!
heart.gif


I've basically given up hope on Glam, so it is PP or bust in this collection for me. I will wait and see if any of the ES show up at the CCO like last year's did.
 

Innatchka

Well-known member
Not to mention taupe. Fiction is my favorite of the ES as well. It seems like a taupe eyeshadow comes out every time I turn around, or maybe that is just my imagination.
Yes forgot about taupe!! I love taupe. .but I have so many already from diffrrent brands..matte, glitter, sparkle..you name it! One of my biggest pet peeves is too have too many colours in the same colour category, only somewhat lighter or darker. I can never choose! Same thing with lipsticks. For example the ones from the AAO collection, that's like a horrifying scenario for me:p I like the colours and glad people enjoy them..but I like to keep it simple: a red lipstick, a pink, coral etc. When I run out I go and find a new similar shade. I rarely buy anything twice or buy backups. I guess I am weird like that:p Right now I have Riri Woo, perfectly happy with it if I want bright red lips. Toxic tale if I want a bright coral look. So thats why I havent voted for Rozz and Tomango.
 

Addict4MAC

Well-known member
Glam is allowed to
greengrin.gif
And yes fail on Mac's part again (ow wait no we are hackers so I guess it's our own fault
th_rolleye0014.gif
)
I was just going to mention how we are the hackers and it wasn't "fair" that we ordered pre-launch.
finger.gif
MAC..



You know...I think I would be more content with Hoop and Flavour being top 3 if we were truly only able to vote once. But since its apparent people are using programs to cheat, I really don't respect the top 3 and will definitely skip the lipsticks if Pink Poodle, Hoop, and Flavor win.
th_dunno.gif
Money saved.
 

Innatchka

Well-known member
I am really out of the loop about the hacker thing. But if its true it would be kind of sad! I mean its just a lipstick..and this voting thing should be fun. I am def not going to obsess over it and vote everyday like crazy.
 

Addict4MAC

Well-known member
I am really out of the loop about the hacker thing. But if its true it would be kind of sad! I mean its just a lipstick..and this voting thing should be fun. I am def not going to obsess over it and vote everyday like crazy.
Yep. I've read that last year people used programs to let them vote multiple times with "one vote" ...like it clicks really fast for you so you don't have to. And people who have witnessed this last year are seeing the same patterns that indicate the same thing is happening this year. I just think it takes the thrill out of the collection. It's bad enough the colors aren't really that unique.
ssad.gif
 

Pinkdollface

Well-known member
Yep. I've read that last year people used programs to let them vote multiple times with "one vote" ...like it clicks really fast for you so you don't have to. And people who have witnessed this last year are seeing the same patterns that indicate the same thing is happening this year. I just think it takes the thrill out of the collection. It's bad enough the colors aren't really that unique.
ssad.gif
I don't mind 1 or two neutral or tame colours (like Pink Poodle, Hoop and Flavour) in the top 3, but I wish there would be just one bright in there as well. I'm sad Rozz is in 4th place right now:( I didn't know people were using those programs last year already. I only knew you could multiple vote when doing it all yourself back then.
 

martiangurll

Well-known member
I think I am over it. Why MAC would reject orders obtained "by illegitimate means" using you know our superpower hacker skillz and all, yet to allow the multiple voting and macros to swing the votes just is inconsistent in a way that raises my hackles. Not voting any more. And I am so on Team Anti PP. I do think that most MAC buyers probably love hot pink and nude colors though. So, I won't be too surprised if those win.
 

ChosenOne

Well-known member
Just cast my vote and the current voting stands at:

PP in 1st
Hoop in 2nd
Rozz in 3rd

Flavour is over 2,000 votes behind Rozz right now, and Glam and Tomango are way behind. I voted Glam anyway.
 

MissTania

Well-known member



Glam matte lipstick, batch code ending in 7, I think I got it on vacation in Spain or Czech republic in 2008. I have barely used it, I like a more pinkish red.

I'm voting Hoop, Rozz and Flavour.
 

elkaknits

Well-known member
eh that amazes me. I went through 2 or 3 tubes a year for a long long time. I have been out forever. Did you get moxie last year? That sounds more your alley.

I am still wishing for more glam but I feel it is hopeless. I am clicking away as much as humanly possible {yes I am cheating!!!!!!!} but in the time it takes me to vote 25 times that pink thing went up over 2000 votes.
 

elkaknits

Well-known member
Gregory Arlt wrote on his fb

Ok....here's how I see it....Pink Poodle lipstick seems to be in the lead, but MAC already has it in Lipglass (and let's face it- it was pretty sheer and we're all about mattes these days, now aren't we??) and there is NOTHING like Glam lipstick. Nothing. Well, except for Love Goddess which I'd created for the Marilyn Monroe collection and is now GONE. So there! ;)

so now I find out pink poodle is a semi-sheer frost? seriously?

and no love goddess is nowhere near as red as glam. Pulls way more pink. But then my memory could be wrong. Maybe i will mix Love Goddess and Red to do a quasi glam ;sighs:
 

sagehen

Well-known member
Gregory Arlt wrote on his fb

Ok....here's how I see it....Pink Poodle lipstick seems to be in the lead, but MAC already has it in Lipglass (and let's face it- it was pretty sheer and we're all about mattes these days, now aren't we??) and there is NOTHING like Glam lipstick. Nothing. Well, except for Love Goddess which I'd created for the Marilyn Monroe collection and is now GONE. So there! ;)

so now I find out pink poodle is a semi-sheer frost? seriously?

and no love goddess is nowhere near as red as glam. Pulls way more pink. But then my memory could be wrong. Maybe i will mix Love Goddess and Red to do a quasi glam ;sighs:
Your memory is not wrong. I have both and they are nowhere near the same.
 

liba

Well-known member
Gregory Arlt wrote on his fb

Ok....here's how I see it....Pink Poodle lipstick seems to be in the lead, but MAC already has it in Lipglass (and let's face it- it was pretty sheer and we're all about mattes these days, now aren't we??) and there is NOTHING like Glam lipstick. Nothing. Well, except for Love Goddess which I'd created for the Marilyn Monroe collection and is now GONE. So there! ;)

so now I find out pink poodle is a semi-sheer frost? seriously?

and no love goddess is nowhere near as red as glam. Pulls way more pink. But then my memory could be wrong. Maybe i will mix Love Goddess and Red to do a quasi glam ;sighs:
I think what he's referring to is the quality of the pigmentation plus the richness of the color, so that it changes a lot in different lights. I remember Glam, although I didn't own it, but I do have Love Goddess and that's the main thing about LG - very complex, multi-faceted color. Colors like that are pretty rare, just because they usually use some pigments that are quite costly and/or have a really complicated pigment mix, with many different pigments mixed together rather than one or two basic ones with a little white or black. It's not that they're dupes, just that they're both very complicated, classic reds with a twist.
 

ForeverJenn

Well-known member
I SO hope something magical happens and we get Glam, Tomango and Rozz in the top 3. lol
Rozz was in second place last time I checked! :) I think people are still afraid to wear orange lips, might seem to bold? I want tomango but Sadly I think there's only a small portion of people who feel comfortable in those type of colors. I'm still scratching my head and not understanding why Glam is so far behind! As Liba said, it's a classic red with a twist! I personally love it and the name. :( Guess people are all "redded-out". I can never have too many reds or fuchsia lip colours (they're my go to's) , but in this case I don't care enough for pink poodle. I want Glam! :rant:
 
Top