MAC by Request (April 1,2014)

[elkaknits]

I guess I should be happy... if Glam, Rozz, and Tomango don't make it that's more money in my pocket! Buuuut, I also want them to make it. So conflicted hboy: The amount of underhanded vote inflation is crazy, though I doubt MAC will do anything about it. Remember when everyone was scared last year that they'd take the "real" tallies of By Request LOL. I'm sure that whatever wins at the end of the 21st is what we'll see next year. Maybe when hardly anything sells out, they'll see. -nods-

Flavor went up by 101 votes overnight. If you compare that to the 30000 for day and you get a good idea of real demand. My beloved glam went up 2000 votes overnight and hoop plus pink thing didn't move at all. Not even 10 votes. sMH

 

[ARmakeupjunkie]

The way some of you feel about Pink Poodle is how I feel about F & H. I'm not a neutral lip kinda girl so I don't understand why both of these are in the top three.

 

[Addict4MAC]

I could see if these shades were going to be made permanent...but they're not. So why vote for so many neutrals in one collection? All of the eye shadows are dark. All of the lipsticks are pink/nude. I'm really about to just give up on this collection.

 

[amynicolaox]

I really wish Pink Poodle would drop out the top 3, but that's such a long shot.. Out of Hoop and Flavour I prefer Flavour and I don't think both need to make it necessarily so I'm going to focus my attention on Flavour

 

[stacekang]

Wtf pink poodles at 143990 ?!?!

 

[Addict4MAC]

It's so frustrating...I'm just going to go back to T's reviews and look at the dupes list again for Butterscotch and call it a day.

 

[Eleentje]

I'm now fully devoting myself to voting for Rozz (although I am not able to do mutliple voting, just multiple computers + phone).
Will give Butterscotch some love as well, as there is too much grey in the lead.

I actually won't mind if Hoop will be in top 3, as that's a neutral I may be able to pull off.

 

[ladyarwen]

I've completely given up on Tomango (and it looks like everyone else has as well), so my lipstick vote is going to Hoop. If Hoop and Rozz make it in, I'll be happy. And there's no way Fiction isn't making it.

 

[raych1984]

I could see if these shades were going to be made permanent...but they're not. So why vote for so many neutrals in one collection? All of the eye shadows are dark. All of the lipsticks are pink/nude. I'm really about to just give up on this collection.

Me too

 

[martiangurll]

I've completely given up on Tomango (and it looks like everyone else has as well), so my lipstick vote is going to Hoop. If Hoop and Rozz make it in, I'll be happy. And there's no way Fiction isn't making it.

thats too bad, I have fiction and its a gorgeous color. I will see if any of my other greens are dupes for it...I think I recall I have something that is fairly similar in my stash...

 

[kimibos]

thats too bad, I have fiction and its a gorgeous color. I will see if any of my other greens are dupes for it...I think I recall I have something that is fairly similar in my stash...

maybe from urban decay???

 

[elkaknits]

going to bed early tonight... while chomping on hard candies in voting frustration I lost a crown and had to go in for emergency dental so am tired

Todays tallies

PP 101089-144065 =42976 or close to 50% gain in less than 24 hours {its a miracle}
Rozz 94226-120672 =26446 vote gain
Hoop 113444-126444 =13000 vote gain
Tomango 25727-25832 = a been given up on 105 vote gain
Glam 48982-50720 = a sad dental emergency gain of 1738 votes
Flavour 103815-104795 = 980 votes

 

[ladyarwen]

thats too bad, I have fiction and its a gorgeous color. I will see if any of my other greens are dupes for it...I think I recall I have something that is fairly similar in my stash...

Oh no, there's no way it ISN'T making it in. Meaning it will certainly make it. XD

 

[LizzyLuv23]

I honestly don't want to give up on Tomango but it's too far behind. I'm team rozz and hoop even though I started being team pp but major votes have been tomango and for eyeshadow, it has been butterscotch! !

 

[martiangurll]

maybe from urban decay???

I think Sumptious Olive is actually pretty close. I forgot to check. Maybe it was Summer Neutral...

Actually Greensmoke is most similar in terms of texture and color. Fiction has better color payoff and pigmentation though.

If I can figure out how to upload, I will swatch Fiction with other similar muted greens.

 

[NaomiH]

Every time I go vote, I shed a tear for poor Tomango and Glam.

 

[elkaknits]

the nightly numbers report

PP 144065-174151 a gain of 30086
Rozz 120672-133708 a gain of 13036
Hoop 126444-130759 a gain of 4315
Tomango 25832-25914 a gain of 82

Glam

50720-69433 a gain of 18713 { thanks to all who are voting along with me btw... I refuse to give up hope}
Flavour 104795-128670 a gain of 23875

 

[sagehen]

Every time I go vote, I shed a tear for poor Tomango and Glam.

me too...

 

[LipstickVixen27]

the nightly numbers report PP 144065-174151 a gain of 30086 Rozz 120672-133708 a gain of 13036 Hoop 126444-130759 a gain of 4315 Tomango 25832-25914 a gain of 82  Glam  50720-69433 a gain of 18713 { thanks to all who are voting along with me btw... I refuse to give up hope} Flavour 104795-128670 a gain of 23875

My top 3 in the top 3 !! Team Pink Poodle

 

[TwistedFaith]

Throwing all my votes to Rozz and Butterscotch! I will be so sad if those don't make it into the top three. As of now, it looks like Rozz has regained 2nd place status!