Okay, I finally took a look at the collection and here are my notes:
To Pamper: Looks almost exactly like Call My Bluff. I swatched them side by side and everything. To Pamper may be a tiny fraction of a shade cooler.
Schemer (The Jew in me in dying to call this "schmear"): A pleasant surprise. Sheer gold with sparklies for a day look. I'll consider this one, but I don't really NEED it.
Docile: Sheer pink. Pretty, but kinda vanished upon application.
Best of Breed: Decent substitute if you missed out on Comet Blue DG.
Palace Pedigreed Quad: I'm still on the fence about this. I love doing a rosy, smokey eye, but I have a rose e/s trio from Stila. However, this quad is much cooler toned, and clearly different. Not sure if it's worth the $$$ for me.
Eyeliners: Holy crap! If you love liquid eyeliner, these are a mega win. Once dry, they don't budge. The colors are super vivid and opaque. The gold one is just stunning. I might have to get it. The green one (Treat Me Nice) is also pretty, but is a bit more of a forest green than an emerald green to me, so I'm not 100% sold. I'm lousy with liquid liner anyway.
So what did I buy? Some Deborah Lippman nail polish in Bad Romance.