I finally remembered to check out the products I'm interested in on my lunch break today and I was impressed with all of them.
For Effect: amazing! Its very pigmented and if you are looking for a dark gray paint pot, this is the one to get. I hate glitter, and this one seemed to have a good amount without being over obnoxious. I read the review at Temptalia and I was confused, I didn't get too much fallout when I swatched it on my hand. I rubbed over it a few times and the glitter stayed intact. I don't think I would try to use it as an eyeliner like she did, even though its bold and dark enough to do so. Its not smooth like an eyeliner and if you attempt to thin it out and line your eyes with it, glitter is going to fall out. Its nice to get an opinion on it, but I don't think it was used like a paint pot should be used in the review. For Effect will make a great base for grays, blues, and even black shadow. As a matter of fact, its a good base to use, especially with mattes, that way you can set the glitter and still get a pretty glittery effect.
How Beautiful: I really love this BP. It looks brown in the pan, but on the skin its just like what MAC-Guy said, it looks like the Seaside CCB. As a matter of fact, I want to get Seaside now because its compliments How Beautiful well, so I will be able to set it now.
HB swatched fine on me and it offered enough oompf as far as I'm concerned. If you have darker skin, and the color is light, its going to show up... Its not overpowering or glittery, and it offers a nice sheen. Because I am darker, I don't like to go overboard with shimmer and shine. HB is suble, but it pops! I know for sure if you are NW43 and up, you are going to make out good with this BP. Its going to be a great highligher.
What Joy! So pretty. Berries are my thing. I don't like too many of the MAC perm berries, but I love the LE ones. WJ is brighter than Hang Up to me. Brighter can be more flattering and festive especially during the holidays! I didn't think it was too deep, and the white packaging... yes please!
So there is my review on the few things I want. The MES weren't really worth my time this go round. They are just too pastel.
Oh and where are the blushes??? No blush pans this holiday???? that's crazy!
Brown in the pan. On the skin, it shows up with a little gold, a little peach.
When I saw For Effect, I thought about Hocus Pocus. They would work well together
I didn't find it gritty. To each their own. If you can swatch it, do so
HEY! Happy Birthday in advance!
totally agree!