Ok, I am *pissed* about Velvetone. I have about 7 brow hairs total, so I HAVE to draw them on. Stud is a warm brown, & not dark enough for me (plus, way too warm toned.) I went to the MAC counter at Dillard's today (which is all we have here in shitty Wichita) to restock & they were out, & said they'd been out for a while. I check the Goodbye's on the MAC site fairly regularly, & Velvetone has never been on there that I've seen. Last time I bought one (back in May) they had about a dozen-had I known it was going, I would have bought them all. I have tried every brow pencil at Sephora, Dillard's, Ulta & Target, & nothing even comes close. Sorry for my little rant, but this is my final MAC straw. I'm officially done with the brand. No more new purchases, will find a new tinted moisturizer to use, no more pigments (since I already have 82, I definitely don't need anymore).