MAC - Surf Baby Discussion

Iwantitall

Well-known member
I agree its nice to get it before the US but its a nightmare too ! Ordering without many swatches is odd and scary. In fact i only ordered Hibiscus and now im fretting that i didnt order the blush !
Shall i order it ???
 

silentstorm143

Well-known member
I went to see this collection yesterday. Here are my thoughts (I'm paler than NC15 at the moment if someone's interested):

Eye shadows:

- Short Shorts was exactly like Nylon on my hand when I swatched them.
- Swell Baby is a beautiful medium grey, nicely pigmented and pulls quite neutral on me. This one came home with me along with
- Sun Blonde and Surf USA. SB is so ugly that I had to get it. It's not really yellow, not really chartreuse, not really gold. It's kind of a pale greenish mustardy yellow? Any weirder or uglier? It could be cousin to Gorgeous Gold. It's really ugly. Ugly. It's exciting to see what can I come up with it. :)
And while on my way to the counter I kept thinking don't get Surf USA, because you have enough teals and turquoises to last a lifetime. Yet I got it. It was greener and more electric than I thought, really pigmented! I couldn't think of an exact dupe while I was there so I had to get it. I might find one that is somewhat similar if I go through my stash, but not many that's for sure. It's greener and brighter than Shimmermoss, and also darker than Aquadisiac.
- Saffron is divine, I thought about getting a backup of it, but I've never needed one so I let it be.

There was only one pigment stack on the display (the blue one), the other one comes later. The colours were pigmented, the platinum and gold were very metallic, high shine frost, like foil. The texture was rough.

Lippies:

- Krazy Kahuna - I was surprised I liked this one! It shows the red/orange undertones beautifully so it's not too brown, it reminded me of Temper Tantra so I was brave and got this one too. It's like a reddish brick colour on my lips.
- Good Lovin' - I got this one even though it's nothing special. Just a neutral peachy pinky nude, I suppose great with any look.
- Strange Potion I got from VV.
- The pale gold gloss was too pale and whiteish for my liking.

- Hibiscus is BRIGHT! It reminded me of Toxic Tale, not quite as neon, and more red. Can't wait to wear it. This will look great with any skin tone like Candy Yum Yum.
- Mocha is something I'm interested in after Temper Tantra turned out to work great for me. I will pick up this later.

Eye pencils:

- Gilded White has a strong gold cast to it, it's like Nylon/Short Shorts in pencil form.
- The teal pencil was like Float On By from To The Beach. Nothing too special.

I didn't get the blush with the overspray. It was quite nice, but to unique enough for me at this point. It's more orange than Fleur Power (FP looked pink next to it) and much much more pigmented and brighter orange than Peaches. I have and love Devil, so I felt I didn't need this one. Also when I blended it in, it had reddish tones coming out and I thought it might look like I had fever/sunburn. Remind you I'm extremely pale now, so it looked insanely bright on my skin, which is good too if one's after those brights. Tested with the overspray, it was very gold and shimmery.

The bronzer sticks weren't there yet so I will check those out later.

Finally I got both nail polishes, they were nice. The pink sandy nude is going to be very nice neutral for summer.

So my haul was
- Swell Baby e/s
- Sun Blonde e/s
- Surf USA e/s
- Krazy Kahuna l/g
- Good Lovin' l/g
- Hibiscus l/s
- Hangin' Loose n/p
- Ocean Dip n/p

If someone here wants some comparison pictures please let me know! :)


Swatches in general would be awesome as for comps swell baby in comparison to perm grays and def sun blonde to the yellows- chrome yellow going bananas if you have it :) great haul and review thanks


So excited for the gray es looks like its going to the THE gray ive been looking for...I want it now
cry.gif
 

BeckyBenett

Well-known member
im so happy for all the uk ladies who managed to order their SB stuff! hope everything arrives nice and pretty!! swatches all around!!
 

ladyarwen

Well-known member
Yikes! I just totaled up my possible bill depending on what I buy, and if I get four of the shadows (most likely skipping Short Shorts), two lipglasses, two lipsticks, both pigment stacks, and My Paradise, that'll bring me to WELL over anything I have spent at MAC previously. This is going to be an expensive hobby...I'll try and bring it down to one lipglass and lipstick. I'm not skimping on the pigment stacks though, those are too gorgeous to pass up.
 

liba

Well-known member
I wasn't really interested in Sun Blonde, but these swatches are turning my head.

I'd love to see a comparison between Sun Blonde and Paparazz-she. Sure, Paparazz-she will be more orange, but if it's in the same vein, I may be able to skip Sun Blonde anyways.
 

GlamQueen21

Well-known member
Swell baby keeps making it's way to may list then keeps leaving, Lol! In some swatches I love it and in others not so much....I so wish I had a store near by so I could see for myself before ordering!

Same here. Swell Baby is starting to make it's way to my list. I'm skipping SUn Blonde since it almost looks like Bright Future from Style Warriors.
 

katred

Specktra Bestie
Thanks for the wonderful and detailed review. I love your description of Sun Blonde and, after seeing swatches, I'm definitely getting that one. I suspected that the blush might be too close to Devil (which I also love) to warrant having both, thanks for helping confirm this.

One question: Did you have a chance to look at Bust Out? I'd be curious to know your opinion.

I went to see this collection yesterday. Here are my thoughts (I'm paler than NC15 at the moment if someone's interested):

Eye shadows:

- Short Shorts was exactly like Nylon on my hand when I swatched them.
- Swell Baby is a beautiful medium grey, nicely pigmented and pulls quite neutral on me. This one came home with me along with
- Sun Blonde and Surf USA. SB is so ugly that I had to get it. It's not really yellow, not really chartreuse, not really gold. It's kind of a pale greenish mustardy yellow? Any weirder or uglier? It could be cousin to Gorgeous Gold. It's really ugly. Ugly. It's exciting to see what can I come up with it. :)
And while on my way to the counter I kept thinking don't get Surf USA, because you have enough teals and turquoises to last a lifetime. Yet I got it. It was greener and more electric than I thought, really pigmented! I couldn't think of an exact dupe while I was there so I had to get it. I might find one that is somewhat similar if I go through my stash, but not many that's for sure. It's greener and brighter than Shimmermoss, and also darker than Aquadisiac.
- Saffron is divine, I thought about getting a backup of it, but I've never needed one so I let it be.

There was only one pigment stack on the display (the blue one), the other one comes later. The colours were pigmented, the platinum and gold were very metallic, high shine frost, like foil. The texture was rough.

Lippies:

- Krazy Kahuna - I was surprised I liked this one! It shows the red/orange undertones beautifully so it's not too brown, it reminded me of Temper Tantra so I was brave and got this one too. It's like a reddish brick colour on my lips.
- Good Lovin' - I got this one even though it's nothing special. Just a neutral peachy pinky nude, I suppose great with any look.
- Strange Potion I got from VV.
- The pale gold gloss was too pale and whiteish for my liking.

- Hibiscus is BRIGHT! It reminded me of Toxic Tale, not quite as neon, and more red. Can't wait to wear it. This will look great with any skin tone like Candy Yum Yum.
- Mocha is something I'm interested in after Temper Tantra turned out to work great for me. I will pick up this later.

Eye pencils:

- Gilded White has a strong gold cast to it, it's like Nylon/Short Shorts in pencil form.
- The teal pencil was like Float On By from To The Beach. Nothing too special.

I didn't get the blush with the overspray. It was quite nice, but to unique enough for me at this point. It's more orange than Fleur Power (FP looked pink next to it) and much much more pigmented and brighter orange than Peaches. I have and love Devil, so I felt I didn't need this one. Also when I blended it in, it had reddish tones coming out and I thought it might look like I had fever/sunburn. Remind you I'm extremely pale now, so it looked insanely bright on my skin, which is good too if one's after those brights. Tested with the overspray, it was very gold and shimmery.

The bronzer sticks weren't there yet so I will check those out later.

Finally I got both nail polishes, they were nice. The pink sandy nude is going to be very nice neutral for summer.

So my haul was
- Swell Baby e/s
- Sun Blonde e/s
- Surf USA e/s
- Krazy Kahuna l/g
- Good Lovin' l/g
- Hibiscus l/s
- Hangin' Loose n/p
- Ocean Dip n/p

If someone here wants some comparison pictures please let me know! :)
 

BeckyBenett

Well-known member
I wasn't really interested in Sun Blonde, but these swatches are turning my head.

I'd love to see a comparison between Sun Blonde and Paparazz-she. Sure, Paparazz-she will be more orange, but if it's in the same vein, I may be able to skip Sun Blonde anyways.
hmm i have paparazz-she too.. dnt have sun blonde bt want to buy it.. im thinking of using the two together (maybe with saffron?) to create a look... need to play with the items once i can buy them. heehee
 

LMD84

Well-known member
hmm i have paparazz-she too.. dnt have sun blonde bt want to buy it.. im thinking of using the two together (maybe with saffron?) to create a look... need to play with the items once i can buy them. heehee
that sounds like a beautiful eye shadow combo! like a sunset perhaps?
 

BeautyByLele

Well-known member
Now im thinking about adding natural eccentric l/s to
mac_wishlist.gif
. Although with my skintone I wonder if it will be to light/ white ?? Im thinking I could pair it with different liners to get a different effect from the lipstick. . .
icon_eek.gif


Awww man that makeup bag looks pretty small. although I like the way it looks. The "large" makeup bag is probably really the size of a medium makeup bag, so this might be a skip for me.

As of right now I have crossed the pig stack off my list.
 

xasperadastra

Well-known member
I can make a comparison between sun blonde and paparazzshe..of course they are really different! I also made a comparison between my paradise and follow your fancy, but I haven't posted it yet!
The little make up bag is cute...buuut for the price is really small...is almost a wallet!!
uhh and I'm going to take bust out and girls on board next week! I'll try to do my best to let you know how bust out looks like!
 

Latest posts

Top