MAC by Request (April 1,2014)

[MACina]

....at least!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This would be great. I mean, I love a pink lipstick as much as the next girl but how many do we need? And could it be a unique pink? I didn't even get into MAC until a couple years ago so I'm sure there are plenty of great shades that I've missed and would love to try.

On a totally different note lol, I was just imagining if they made a Firm-Form like color but with a purple/magenta pearl instead of gold. How pretty would that be?

 

[MACina]

...that would be soooo great!

Chill e/s, MAC? For real? And the other colors? Blah and dupeable, for the most part. I've been so underwhelmed by MAC for the longest time now. MAC By Request is their *perfect* opportunity to show the hell out. Imagine what they could do, the possibilities in a collection like this. Why not bring back some dearly loved PIGMENTS? There are so many of them that people would love to have! I'm bored with you, MAC. Not to mention disappointed.

 

[MACina]

....Turquoise

Seriously!!! I would LOVE if they brought back all the mattes.

 

[Naughtyp]

Now MAC is going to label us hackers using technological means to upset the fairness of their websites and all.

LMAO!!! true dat lol

 

[luvlydee]

I just realized before i clicked my vote for butterscotch that the mua was quoted stating that this was a great highlight for med-dark to dark skin tones. That was the only reason i was voting butterscotch to begin with thinking it might work as a highlight for me lol guess my suspicions were right.

 

[Copperhead]

I just realized before i clicked my vote for butterscotch that the mua was quoted stating that this was a great highlight for med-dark to dark skin tones. That was the only reason i was voting butterscotch to begin with thinking it might work as a highlight for me lol guess my suspicions were right.

I was looking at it thinking about a brow bone highlight.

 

[Mac4Megan]

Have any Canadian's been able to vote yet? The link mac emailed me isn't working

 

[erine1881]

Have any Canadian's been able to vote yet? The link mac emailed me isn't working

Have you tried voting thru FB?

 

[Mac4Megan]

Have you tried voting thru FB?

Yup, the link I got takes me to a FB page that doesn't seem to load properly and I get the same thing when I go directly through FB.

 

[Beautybuyer]

The pinks are okay the bright colors seem repetitive to me?

 

[BriarRose]

Wow. Uh, not particularly enthused by this.

Of the ES, the only ones I find pretty are Fiction (which from T's swatches, looks like it would read way too yellow on me) and Diesel (and really... how many grey eyeshadows do I possibly need?).

The lipsticks, I think, actually all look nice, but as so many of you said, completely dupeable. Pink Poodle is my favorite, but I hate the glaze finish in general.

So I'm not sure what to vote for. Glam is the only other one I know would work on me, but, again, how many reds does one person need? Especially when my favorite lip colors are pink and purple.

The totals as of a few minutes ago are:

Lipsticks
Pink Poodle 4686
Flavour 4645
Hoop 4393
Glam 2849
Rozz 2797
Tomango 2526

Eyeshadows
Butterscotch 6969
Ashbury 2927
Fiction 1879
Chill 1478
Diesel 1429

I'm surprised Flavour is so high up, and Hoop, to be honest.

 

[MACgirl]

The shadows don't surprise me. However the lipstick count does! I know voting just happened but pink poodle is winning? Over glam, tomango, and rozz!???

 

[LavenderPearl]

I'm more surprised about Hoop and Flavour. They're so everyday that there's bound to be a million dupes... also they just shot up in a couple of hours. >> ETA that all of these colors are dupable imo, but they're probably the most.

 

[ForeverJenn]

Wow. Uh, not particularly enthused by this. Of the ES, the only ones I find pretty are Fiction (which from T's swatches, looks like it would read way too yellow on me) and Diesel (and really... how many grey eyeshadows do I possibly need?). The lipsticks, I think, actually all look nice, but as so many of you said, completely dupeable. Pink Poodle is my favorite, but I hate the glaze finish in general. hboy: So I'm not sure what to vote for. Glam is the only other one I know would work on me, but, again, how many reds does one person need? Especially when my favorite lip colors are pink and purple. The totals as of a few minutes ago are: Lipsticks Pink Poodle 4686 Flavour 4645 Hoop 4393 Glam 2849 Rozz 2797 Tomango 2526 Eyeshadows Butterscotch 6969 Ashbury 2927 Fiction 1879 Chill 1478 Diesel 1429 I'm surprised Flavour is so high up, and Hoop, to be honest.

not that they're bad choices but really hoop and flavour in the top 3 as of now?! I really want Rozz :rant: lol

 

[BriarRose]

ETA that all of these colors are dupable imo, but they're probably the most.

That's my take on it too. None of them are all that unique, but those two the least so. They have really high Love It scores on T's site though, so... I dunno.

Yeah, and as a side note... if they wanted it one vote per person per day, perhaps they should have made a program that made it impossible to vote more than once. It can be done on FB, I have seen it. This is an IT fail on their part yet again.

 

[Corally]

I'm surprised Flavour is so high up, and Hoop, to be honest. not that they're bad choices but really hoop and flavour in the top 3 as of now?! I really want Rozz :rant: lol

I know right! And Pink Poodle is nr1 now wth. GIMME ROOOZZZ.

 

[elkaknits]

I too am surprised at how high flavour and hoop are. However, my daughter said she liked hoop the best out of the 6. Yes I had everybody in my family vote for my beloved Glam yesterday. Luckily for me I have 3 kids, each with their own computer, and The Flame. Technically speaking it is not me voting

 

[MACina]

YAY...I really hope that these 3 will make it...they are my faves

But it really surprises me because I would have thought that Rooz,Tomango and Glam would be the top 3 right from
the beginning

Maybe Pink Poodle instead of Glam or Tomango.....but Hoop and Flavor???

The lipsticks, I think, actually all look nice, but as so many of you said, completely dupeable. Pink Poodle is my favorite, but I hate the glaze finish in general.

So I'm not sure what to vote for. Glam is the only other one I know would work on me, but, again, how many reds does one person need? Especially when my favorite lip colors are pink and purple.
The totals as of a few minutes ago are:

Lipsticks
Pink Poodle 4686
Flavour 4645
Hoop 4393
Glam 2849
Rozz 2797
Tomango 2526

Eyeshadows
Butterscotch 6969
Ashbury 2927
Fiction 1879
Chill 1478
Diesel 1429

I'm surprised Flavour is so high up, and Hoop, to be honest.

 

[BriarRose]

YAY...I really hope that these 3 will make it...they are my faves

But it really surprises me because I would have thought that Rooz,Tomango and Glam would be the top 3 right from
the beginning

Maybe Pink Poodle instead of Glam or Tomango.....but Hoop and Flavor???

It's changed now. Pink Poodle is still first, but Rozz is 2nd, and Glam is 3rd. I think it's going to bounce all around until the day it ends.

Tomango is last, 2,000+ votes behind the neutrals and reds. That is really surprising to me, but it does look a lot like SLV and SI to my unprofessional eye, so maybe that's the issue there.

 

[Pinkdollface]

It's changed now. Pink Poodle is still first, but Rozz is 2nd, and Glam is 3rd. I think it's going to bounce all around until the day it ends.
Tomango is last, 2,000+ votes behind the neutrals and reds. That is really surprising to me, but it does look a lot like SLV and SI to my unprofessional eye, so maybe that's the issue there.

People are using macros. I'm pretty sure about that because this morning Glam was +2000 votes lower than it is now.