hey whatever works for you! :cheer: I am definitely in the minority about Blacktrack, but I looooove fluidlines in general and even Blacktrack's got its uses on old Dry Eyes over here! I heard somewhere that the word "moist" is very annoying to a lot of women - like they did some study or survey about yucky words and moist came out near the top for women.

For someone who has had dry skin all her life, "moist" is an awesome word!!! I like "moist" very much for other things too, if you catch my drift

Wholesome isn't shiny, but it does have a bit of a less dense, black hole, light absorbing sort of effect - my Blacktrack sits around unused most of the time, and I use Wholesome instead. I've been wearing my glossy bright Playland lipsticks + glosses a lot lately though, so I've been thinking about pulling out Blacktrack again as a counterpoint to the ultra-shiny hooker lips. I think it'll be a good look with Peachstock gloss, or the nude lipstick from Pedro Lourenço or the interesting textured nudes like Innocent Patent Polish or Woodwinked, since any really skin colored nude lip plus nude face will accentuate the interplay of texture you'd get with such a flat black in the mix.