MAC by Request (April 1,2014)

[CarmenK]

Me too! Guess this collection is a bust.lol

Yes it definitely is lol

 

[elkaknits]

And the exact same glosses just so happen to get voted in as well? I don't think so.

there was no voting for glosses at all.... only lipsticks and eyeshadows. Which is why the glosses are considered a surprise. I like that it has matching glosses even tho I am not a big gloss wearer. Matchy matchy nail polish would have had me on auto purchase and I am not a MAC polish wearer. I think I picked up Studio Rose or whatever from MM just for image sake

 

[kimibos]

And the exact same glosses just so happen to get voted in as well? I don't think so.

there was no voting for the glosses. they just announced them later.

 

[allthingsglam]

that is how I feel about the poodle ... please sell out before I buy uuuuuuuu

I feel the same way pp may be the only one I buy

 

[Dolly Snow]

And the exact same glosses just so happen to get voted in as well? I don't think so.

[exactly, makes no sense

 

[erine1881]

there was no voting for glosses at all.... only lipsticks and eyeshadows.  Which is why the glosses are considered a surprise.  I like that it has matching glosses even tho I am not a big gloss wearer.  Matchy matchy nail polish would have had me on auto purchase and I am not a MAC polish wearer.  I think I picked up Studio Rose or whatever from MM just for image sake

Oh. I guess the colours are just so boring i eliminated the entire thing from my memory :lol:

 

[lipstickjunkie]

Maybe Mac finally realized, hey, if we make more lipsticks we can make a crapload more money instead of making ppl feel like only 1000 were made just for the hell of it... Hmmm... Lml.

 

[lipstickaddict]

They didn't it was people using computer clicker programs.

How lame is that!

 

[Beautybuyer]

How lame is that!

Very! But the options mac gave weren't amazing anyway. I mean how close were hoop and the other pink choice?(sorry forgot the name already lol) They should have taken the most popular colors or did a throw back packaging collection. SOMETHING.

 

[lipstickaddict]

Lol it would go up more than 50 clicks in a second! Like crazy clicking

Lol -Now that I remember, it was very bizarre how certain colors skyrocketed, especially in the last day or two. Glam wasn't even in the running until near the end when it kicked out Rozz--if I remember correctly.

 

[Dolly Snow]

Lol -Now that I remember, it was very bizarre how certain colors skyrocketed, especially in the last day or two. Glam wasn't even in the running until near the end when it kicked out Rozz--if I remember correctly.

I remember it did kick out rozz at the very end, you're right.

 

[DarylandCarole]

Wow that is crazy!  My daughter bought me a Chanel nail polish or lipstick for Christmas.... I forget which because I have been trying not to acquire many things leading up to this release and I purchased one item and received the other as a gift.  I also picked up 2 of the Dior holiday items {minuit} and another Dior nail polish but that is it.  I think.  I will have to go over my purchases to be sure but that is over the course of ummm since last June so 9 months.  Pretty tame if you ask me team low buy for the win

You have really been doing well! I wasn't sure if I was going to buy anything from this, and ended up buying all three. I don't plan on getting the eye shadows, though.

 

[lipstickaddict]

I do admit keiko lynn makes PP look awesome saucy: http://www.keikolynn.com/2010/08/makeup-monday-and-yourkiss.html The post is 4 yrs old and she claims it is her favorite and it does look beautiful on her but then she is obviously a very pretty girl. I cannot imagine much looking bad on her

Uhmmmmm

! Wowza! She is stunning. Now I kinda want PP, although there is no way it is going to look that glam on me--haha! Oh boy...

 

[kimibos]

Lol -Now that I remember, it was very bizarre how certain colors skyrocketed, especially in the last day or two. Glam wasn't even in the running until near the end when it kicked out Rozz--if I remember correctly.

yes. glam was the last one till 1 day before it ended. it actually ended with Rozz having more points. i remember people being mad cause they wanted glam and said mac had to stick to the 12am hr mark.

Rozz and Tomango were the most popular ones in the thread.

 

[CarmenK]

I remember it did kick out rozz at the very end, you're right.

Really wish Rozz or Tomanago wouldve made it. I was most excited about those two.

 

[CarmenK]

Debating getting Pink Poodle but it is just way too similar to Girl about Town to me.

 

[kimibos]

I think mac went too retro with these shades if they had done more recent favorites like Toxic tale, Lollipop loving, Prince Noir, Petals and peacocks, Gladiola etc. the collection would have been more popular.

 

[Dolly Snow]

Really wish Rozz or Tomanago wouldve made it. I was most excited about those two.

I wanted rozz, its so pretty

 

[Dolly Snow]

yes. glam was the last one till 1 day  before it ended. it actually ended with Rozz having more points. i remember people being mad cause they wanted glam and said mac had to stick to the 12am hr mark. Rozz and Tomango were the most popular ones in the thread.

Those two shades were the ones I honestly thought would have made it. Everyone was talking about rozz anf tomango.

 

[CarmenK]

I think mac went too retro with these shades if they had done more recent favorites like Toxic tale, Lollipop loving, Prince Noir, Petals and peacocks, Gladiola etc. the collection would have been more popular.

Omg totally agree! Wouldve loved sweet and sour and blooming lovely too