I'm so upset!
I found dupes for most of them
Legendary black=hocus pocus (and its going back)
make your mark=(almost) carbon
carefree=nylon
sweet satisfaction=romp
hot paprika=(quite similar)coppering
lie low=mulch
one to watch=(quite similar) texture
Pink frontier=(almost) mineral mode
They r almost all going back!
I swatched almost all of these on my forearm last night! First of all, Legendary Black is lighter and more taupe than Keep Your Cool, which is almost black with slightly smoked plum nanoglitters. Keep Your Cool was to me quite unique and gorgeous and I could not think of any dupes. I don;t think it looks quite like Carbon because of the nanoglitters which add an extra dimension to it. (No offense Priarpeet!) Plus the texture makes it stand out--dramatically. Carbon is quite flat and one dimensional, this is just lovely--my second favorite of the bunch.
Weathered was simply beautiful, and I am on the fence about it because it is so unique and lovely but I just cannot justify another greyed blue because I really like the one that came in the Lady Justice WW quad, and I will never use both in a lifetime. You cannot appreciate the shimmery nanoglitters of stormy blue and blue gray from a monitor and need to see this IRL. I will probably get this anyway, because it was my favorite of the bunch and I know like with the Peacocky shadows, even if I have dupes, I will probably swap the dupes because the texture of these is just a delight to work with!
I love the baby blue one (Styledriven) It was simply beautiful and the texture was buttery. I hardly ever wear blues, but I will get this one just because it is such a delight to work with.
I did not think SS looks that much like Romp, I think it is much lighter and more golden beige, but then again, I did not swatch them side by side and I am going on memory.
I agree Hot Paprika is very similar to Coppering and not all that unique (but beautiful and again, the texture is lovely) Probably not worth $20 if you aren't on Team Orange.
Pink Frontier was the most metallic/frosty of the bunch and that made me not want it, although the delicate light pinkness of it was beautiful. If the finish was more like Satin, it would have been a keeper.
I don't have Mulch, so cannot compare it to Lie Low, but this was a beautiful color and I will definitely annex this to my collection when my wallet isn't exhausted buying LE items.
I don't have Hocus Pocus yet, so I cannot compare to Legendary Black, but this color disappointed me because it wasn't black at all and it wasn't unique enough to call itself legendary, so I am skipping it just for having a presumptious name.
I am quite glad these are permanent because I know I am going to do a Peacocky manouvre and go back for them again and again because the texture is just so delicious--I want to eat these up. Again if you have dupes of these, I would consider how much you love the finish of the dupes, because the texture is so buttery, I can justify purchase of any of these for that reason alone.