I am so in love with this collection! Like someone else said, I have to keep reminding myself that it's permanent so I can pace myself. Here's my review:
Eyeshadow: I bought Carefree, Pink Frontier, Sweet Satisfaction, Lie Low, Make your Mark, and Hot Paprika. I will probably go back and get Legendary Black and Keep your Cool (or maybe Weathered) sometime soon. I do agree that these are somewhat dupable, but the formula more than makes up for that. With MAC shadows, I always had the problem, especially with darker shadows, of them migrating along my crease throughout the day. I would do a dark shadow on the outer crease, and within a few hours it would have "run" into my inner crease. I tried paint pots, NARS primer, etc. and continued to have the problem, but not with these! They are fantastic. I have found that the color does fade ever so faintly throughout the day, but most of the color still remains. I have not experienced any movement or creasing at all. I think the color selection is fantastic too. I own way too many MAC shadows because the collection is so huge. I always feel like I'm missing out on the next great thing. I appreciate the basic nature of this selection, but with enough variety that it has something to offer everyone. I have actually taken my other MAC palettes out of the bathroom for now! (Speaking of palettes, anyone have any great palettes for these new pans? I think they're 36mm.)
Liners: I bought Staunchly Stylish. This is a great color, very similar than my natural lip color, though a bit lighter and pinker. It's a great base and can probably even be worn on it's own though it might be a little dry. It hangs on for dear life and doesn't budge. I wasn't too thrilled with the color options for this product. Many of the colors are VERY similar and I wish they had something a little lighter.
Lipstick: A new love. I never purchased anything from the previous PLW line, because there was never a color that really stood out to me. I bought Soft Sell and it is absolutely gorgeous. It's a very natural pink on me that doesn't lean too pastel, too berry, or too fuchsia. It's not a particularly summery pink I think it will translate well even in the fall and winter. It adds a "glow" to my lips that I can't quite explain. It's similar to what Chanel Boy did if you're familiar with that, though Boy is much lighter and sheerer. It's just a glow-from-within look that I adore. Tangent: Some of the blogs I have read seem to mix up Soft Sell and To the Future. I tried both in the store and Soft Sell is definitely the darker of the two. It's a natural pink whereas To the Future is the lighter peachy color. I was actually really hoping that it would work for me too because it's a fantastic color in the tube, but it didn't work at all. My natural lips are quite pigmented, and the creaminess of this just looked like a streaky mess. If anyone has any tips on how to make this work (besides concealing my whole lip), please share. I love the color but couldn't make it work.
Lipgloss: Wow. I bought Show Me and Whoops and both are great. The formula is definitely thick and takes a little getting used to, but it does hang on! I know some people have complained of streakiness or difficulty in application, but i have not experienced this with either of these colors. They do make my lips peel (?) a little, for lack of a better word, but now that I've been wearing it consistently for several days, it doesn't seem to be a problem. Maybe my lips are fully exfoliated now.

Show Me looks great on top of Soft Sell and Whoops is great even on it's own. I would like to get more of these in the future, but none of the other colors really call me right now.
This is my first post and it looks like I wanted to make it count! For reference, I'm NW20 with light brown hair and blue eyes.